When Sarah and her husband, Jeff, discovered an old ice house tucked away in the middle of York, Pennsylvania, they had big dreams for it - a place that married Sarah’s love of beautiful design with her passion for helping people create warm memories in their homes.

Apples were a favorite fruit of their daughter, and gray was a color loved by Sarah. Little did they know that “Gray Apple” was the perfect metaphor – this once unassuming, neglected space was transformed into a charming shopping destination that’s adored by the community and beyond.

Every product is handpicked and your experience is carefully curated by Sarah. From the moment you step into our shop, all of your senses are stimulated to evoke a sense of nostalgia. It is our hope that the shop represents all that brings comfort to your home.